No reason to delete, and might be expandable, perhaps by adding covers they've done (like my personal fave, Rhinestone Cowboy). It provides a look at the genesis of their discography, and is valuable for research purposes. Popcornduff ( talk) 08:56, 23 July 2017 (UTC) I say keep it. I'm really in two minds about whether we need it or not. Now those songs and many others have been released on A Moon Shaped Pool and the recent OK Computer reissue (and in some cases now have their own pages), the list on this page has become rather thin. Numerous publications had covered some of these songs in some depth, especially Lift, True Love Waits, and Man of War. Is this page useful? Should we keep it? Popcornduff ( talk) 08:55, 23 July 2017 (UTC)īackground info: When I created this page a couple of years ago, Radiohead were notorious for unreleased songs. Popcornduff ( talk) 08:29, 2 February 2017 (UTC) Request for comment: do we still need this article? Ī few of the songs on this page are simply titles mentioned in interviews, with no known performances or recording history. For more details, read WP:YouTube and WP:OR. YouTube videos are also not the best sources. We can't just say "I saw it on the internet." We have to wait until a trusted source says "I saw it on the internet" instead. Instead, we have to use sources with some editorial oversight, reliability, etc. contribs) 07:07, 2 February 2017 (UTC) I'm afraid that's against Wikipedia policy.Preceding unsigned comment added by Agidor Rodiga ( talk It's arbitrary to have to wait for someone at Rolling Stone to watch the exact same video all of us can watch with our own eyes (and ears). Popcornduff ( talk) 03:01, 10 June 2016 (UTC) But the Rolling Stone contributor might very well be doing just what this person did: watching the YouTube video. A YouTube video doesn't cut it we need to find a book or music journal (like Rolling Stone or Pitchfork or something) that mentions it. I'd really like to, but I can't find a reliable source for it. How about including "I Promise", played live between March and August 1996 So Silent Spring was adapted into the song "The Numbers" and released today on A Moon Shaped Pool. (I intend to remove all the unsourced original research soon, but don't want to violate 3RR.) Popcornduff ( talk) 13:36, (UTC) "Silent Spring"
Is there any logical way to order this list? Does the current order have any purpose? Mechanic1c ( talk) 21:30, (UTC) It's in chronological order, or at least it was until the previous editor added a lot of stuff I'm not sure if it still is. 4 Request for comment: do we still need this article?.
0 kommentar(er)
